Federal prosecutors in Manhattan say they have taken down one of the largest no fault insurance fraud operations in history. On Wednesday, January 12, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York announced charges against 13 people in two separate indictments tied to an alleged $100 million scheme.
According to the Justice Department, the case grew out of an investigation with the FBI, the NYPD and the Westchester County District Attorney’s Office. Among those charged are licensed doctors, a New York attorney, a paralegal and an NYPD officer.
How the alleged scheme worked
Prosecutors say the defendants took advantage of New York and New Jersey no fault insurance laws, which require insurers to cover medical costs for people hurt in car accidents. According to the indictments, the groups obtained confidential information about accident victims, steered those victims to clinics they controlled, and then billed insurance companies for treatments that were unnecessary.
The first group, which prosecutors say was led by four non physicians including a man identified as Alexander, allegedly ran more than a dozen medical corporations and billed insurers more than $30 million. The NYPD officer charged in that case is accused of pulling confidential accident reports from department computers during off hours and passing them along so victims could be steered to the group’s clinics. He is charged with making false statements to federal agents.
Two licensed practitioners in that case are accused of prescribing unnecessary and excessive treatments, and a New York lawyer is accused of laundering hundreds of thousands of dollars for the group’s leaders and lying to law enforcement.
The second group, which prosecutors say was led by a man identified as Bradley, allegedly controlled five medical service companies and billed insurers more than $70 million. Two doctors in that case are accused of ordering unnecessary electrodiagnostic tests and inflating MRI findings to keep referrals coming, while a paralegal and a runner allegedly helped gather patient information.
What they face
The charges are allegations, and every defendant is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. According to the Justice Department, the maximum possible sentences range from five years for some defendants to more than 40 years for the alleged leaders of the first group.
Made to order and shipped to your door.
FBI Assistant Director Michael Driscoll said schemes like this one cost insurers millions of dollars and that the cost “is almost always passed to consumers of private insurance or subsidized programs established to help those in need.”


