The Apple FBI hearing is underway on Capitol Hill, where Apple and the FBI took their fight over a locked iPhone straight to the House Judiciary Committee on Tuesday.
The hearing, titled “The Encryption Tightrope: Balancing Americans’ Security and Privacy,” started at 1 pm Eastern. FBI Director James Comey, Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance and Apple general counsel Bruce Sewell are all testifying, according to the committee.
At the center of it all is an iPhone 5C owned by San Bernardino County and used by Syed Farook, the county health inspector who, along with his wife Tashfeen Malik, killed 14 people in the December shooting before both died in a gun battle with police, the Associated Press reported. A federal magistrate judge in California, Sheri Pym, ordered Apple to help the FBI get into the phone under the All Writs Act, a law from 1789 that lets courts issue the orders they need to carry out their work. Apple filed its formal objection to that order in court Tuesday, setting up an appeal.
Comey told lawmakers the bureau cannot get into the phone without Apple writing new code for it, and that the question reaches far beyond one case. In the AP’s account, he described the request this way: “We’re asking Apple to take the vicious guard dog away and let us pick the lock.” He also said that in the end, Congress will have to decide where the line belongs.
Sewell told the committee Apple is in an arms race with criminals and hackers, and that a court order is the wrong place to settle a question this big, according to the committee’s account. In his prepared statement, he said the FBI wants Apple to create an operating system that does not exist because building it would be too dangerous, a tool that could break the encryption protecting personal information on every iPhone.
Vance brought the local view. State and local agencies handle about 95 percent of criminal cases, the committee noted, and the AP reported he told lawmakers his investigators have 205 phones they cannot get into.
Apple came into the Apple FBI hearing with momentum. On Monday, U.S. Magistrate Judge James Orenstein in Brooklyn ruled that the government could not force Apple to help unlock an iPhone in a drug case, finding that the Justice Department’s use of the All Writs Act would lead to absurd results. He also pointed out that Congress has already weighed legislation that would require companies like Apple to open locked phones for law enforcement and has not passed it.
Made to order and shipped to your door.
The committee says it wants a solution that lets law enforcement do its job without hurting American encryption companies or the privacy of everyday people. With one federal judge ordering Apple to help and another ruling it cannot be forced, the people who write the laws are now being asked to sort it out.


