A Long Island couple has been arrested and charged after a Black neighbor in Valley Stream accused them of racially harassing her for years, according to the Nassau District Attorney’s office.
John, 57, was charged with criminal mischief and harassment after allegedly shooting pellet guns and dumping dog feces in his neighbor Jennifer’s yard, among other alleged scare tactics. A DA spokesperson said his girlfriend, Mindy, 53, was charged with criminal tampering.
Jennifer, 39, a registered nurse, put a sign on her lawn last month saying in part that her neighbors had been racially harassing her since she bought her home and that she lived in fear. The photo spread on social media and drew attention from the county executive, Laura Curran, local activists and residents, and activists marched through Valley Stream in support. Jennifer had previously tried to get a restraining order.
She told the Daily News that the neighbors told her to go back to where she came from. She also claimed that dead squirrels and feces were left near her home, and she pointed to video she says shows guns and John wearing blackface.
John has denied the allegations. Days before his arrest he said Jennifer’s claim that he threatened to have her erased was “absolutely absurd and untrue,” adding that his family has lived in Valley Stream since 1964 and that he wishes her and her child well.
Police were called nearly 50 times between the two households, starting when Jennifer moved to the block in 2017. A spokeswoman for Nassau District Attorney Madeline Singas said investigators had been in regular contact with Jennifer and her lawyer and that the investigation was ongoing.
John and Mindy appeared in court on Monday to hear the charges and were released on their own recognizance, but a judge ordered them to stay away from Jennifer. Her lawyer said the arrest was long overdue and that she had felt unsafe in her own home. The couple has since moved out of the Valley Stream house, while John’s father remains.
Made to order and shipped to your door.
The charges are allegations, and John and Mindy are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.



