Pammy Maye was sentenced to 29 years to life in prison Thursday. Before that happened, she turned on her own attorney in front of a packed Columbus courtroom.
Video:
Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Mark Serrott opened the hearing by warning everyone to keep order. Maye stood up anyway and shouted at defense attorney Samuel Shamansky, “You are the Antichrist! Yes, you are!” Deputies held her in her chair. When Shamansky tried to calm her down, she told him, “No! I don’t want your help. You’re the Antichrist.” She was taken out of the courtroom.
When deputies brought her back a few minutes later, Shamansky told the judge he was withdrawing because Maye had complained about how he represented her and no longer wanted his help. Serrott asked her why. Maye said Shamansky “represented me like he was a prosecutor instead of defending me,” and claimed the footage shown about her had been edited.
The judge pushed her on it, and Maye said her lawyer kept saying she was guilty. Serrott cut her off. “You confessed to the crime, ma’am,” he said. Maye answered, “I know that.” When she kept talking, the judge told her, “Don’t interrupt me. I get to interrupt you.”
Serrott then told Maye to keep her attorney. He said he watched Shamansky fight hard for her, and that he gave “one of the best closing arguments I’ve ever seen with nothing really to work with.” Maye got up again and talked about God’s wrath. She claimed she had been possessed by demons until Jesus visited her a month ago. Shamansky stayed at the defense table for the rest of the hearing.
Darnell’s family filled the courtroom and gave victim impact statements about a happy, loving little boy. They asked the judge for life without parole. Maye cried while they spoke. When she got another chance to speak, her tone changed. “I was very selfish,” she said. “He was a loving child. He was a perfect child.”
Made to order and shipped to your door.
Shamansky asked the court to weigh her mental health. He told the judge she is not “the devil these people claim,” and described her as a woman who suffers deeply from mental illness. Serrott said a photo of Darnell after his death haunts him. Then he gave Maye life in prison with the possibility of parole after 29 years. Maye is 51, so the earliest she could go before a parole board is when she is 80.
Last week a Franklin County jury found her guilty on all five counts: aggravated murder, abuse of a corpse and three counts of tampering with evidence. Jurors deliberated for about two hours. The defense had asked for a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity. Both sides agreed Maye has a mental illness, but the jury sided with prosecutors, who argued she knew what she was doing was wrong.
Maye and her husband, Jabrell Maye, got temporary legal custody of Darnell in May 2023. On February 14, 2024, she put a black plastic garbage bag over his head and suffocated him inside their Columbus home. She told investigators she was angry because she found out he had eaten snacks in bed. She hid his body in a closet, washed the bedsheets, and then left his body in a storm drain in southwest Columbus.
Early that morning, Maye woke her husband up and told him she had hurt the child. He called 911 just after 3 a.m., and Columbus police put out a statewide Amber Alert. Darnell’s body was found in the storm drain almost 48 hours later. Police found her abandoned Jeep Cherokee in Brooklyn, a suburb of Cleveland. She was arrested the next night after a business owner reported a woman walking around outside a building in a nightgown.
The case took more than two and a half years to reach trial. A judge first found Maye unfit to stand trial. She was declared competent in May 2026. In July, prosecutors offered her a deal to plead guilty to aggravated murder and abuse of a corpse, which would have made her eligible for parole years earlier. She turned it down at a hearing where deputies removed her after she started screaming “God is dead.” In November 2024, a wrongful death lawsuit was filed against her. It alleges Maye abused Darnell for years before she killed him.


