A new Nolan Wells video published this week shows seven people aboard the boat that left Horn Island on the Fourth of July, and Wells does not appear among them. The footage and accompanying photos surfaced Monday through “The Officer Tatum Show,” the YouTube channel run by Brandon Tatum, and were picked up more widely Tuesday morning. The clip is being described in much of the coverage as proof that Wells never boarded, which overstates what it actually establishes. Seven people are visible. Wells is not one of them. That is the extent of it.
Video
The distinction matters because the footage does not contradict the account his friends have given since the beginning. They have consistently said Wells chose to stay on the island with a young woman he had met that day rather than ride back with the group. If that account is accurate, his absence from the boat is exactly what the video should show. What the video does not answer is the question the investigation has been circling for three weeks, which is what happened on Horn Island after 4:31 p.m.Wells, 18, was from Ocean Springs and played football at Southwest Mississippi Community College. He traveled to the barrier island in Jackson County on July 4 with a group of friends for the holiday. He was reported missing that night when he never came home. On the morning of July 6, a U.S. park ranger found his body in shallow water off the northwestern tip of the island, near the stretch of shoreline where the group had anchored. Currents in that water are known to be dangerous.The timeline that investigators have assembled is narrow. Around 4 p.m. on July 4, someone aboard the boat called Sea Tow to report that the bilge pump had failed and the vessel was taking on water. Mississippi’s Department of Marine Resources released that recording on July 26. A young voice on the call tells the dispatcher they are sinking and asks for help. The dispatcher then asks whether everyone on board is in good health, and the caller responds that everybody is on board.That single line is the friction point in the entire Nolan Wells video story. It was said at roughly 4 p.m. Wells was not on the boat. Whether the caller meant the whole group was accounted for, or simply that everyone with him at that moment was safe and aboard the vessel, is not something the recording resolves on its own. It is also the kind of ambiguity that gets flattened in a headline and hardens into a claim by the third or fourth outlet that repeats it.
Sea Tow never completed the tow. Another vessel anchored nearby pulled the disabled boat instead, and the group eventually got the engine working and finished the run to shore themselves. GPS data reviewed by the Jackson County investigation puts the boat leaving Horn Island at approximately 4:31 p.m. and back at its original departure point at 5:44 p.m. Wells’ friends have said that someone reported seeing him on the island around 6 p.m., after the boat had already docked. The sister of the young woman he stayed with has said she was under the impression Wells was leaving with the group and that the friends would not have left him behind.
His parents, Christine Wonsley and Elmore Wonsley, have rejected the idea that their son stayed voluntarily. Attorney Ben Crump, who represents the family, has said they believe strongly that Wells would not have stayed behind and would not have left his cell phone. The family commissioned its own investigation and an independent autopsy separate from the state’s. Those results were presented publicly on July 22 at the NAACP Convention in Chicago, and the cause and manner of death were listed as undetermined pending investigation. Mississippi authorities have said they suspect drowning. The family does not accept that conclusion.
The official file remains closed to the public, and the district attorney has explained why in unusually direct terms. Jackson County District Attorney Angel Myers McIlrath released a video statement on July 23 confirming that the autopsy report will be withheld until a grand jury reviews it, and noting that every death in the county except natural causes and non criminal car wrecks goes before a grand jury as a matter of standard practice. Her office has emphasized that convening one does not indicate criminality. In a follow up statement she said Mississippi’s rules of professional conduct restrict what a prosecutor can disclose during an active investigation, and she warned that there is a heck of a lot of misinformation circulating about the case.
That warning is worth holding onto as footage keeps surfacing through channels that are not news organizations. The dock video that appeared last week, the boat clip that may show Wells hours before he died, and now this one have all reached the public through YouTube and celebrity outlets rather than through investigators. Each has been framed as a break in the case. None has been authenticated publicly by the sheriff’s department or the district attorney.
The FBI’s Jackson office has assisted with certain aspects of the investigation. The Congressional Black Caucus has publicly backed the family’s call for an independent review, saying too many questions remain unanswered. Crump’s team is coordinating its own examination of Wells’ cell phone alongside law enforcement. Tyler Perry covered the cost of the funeral, which was held at Center Pointe Church in Ocean Springs.
What the new Nolan Wells video adds is confirmation of a detail nobody was disputing. What the case still lacks is any official account of the roughly two days between the moment that boat pulled away and the moment a park ranger found an 18 year old in the water a short distance from where his friends had anchored.
