A New Jersey judge is facing criticism after saying a teenage boy accused of a serious sexual assault deserved leniency because he comes from a good family, according to reporting at the time.
Judge James Troiano of Superior Court in Monmouth County denied a prosecutor’s request to try the 16 year old as an adult. Prosecutors had described the alleged conduct as sophisticated and predatory. The judge said the teen came from a good family and an excellent school and was a strong candidate for a good college. He also questioned whether the incident met the legal definition of rape. Critics said those remarks put the accused teen’s future ahead of the seriousness of the accusation.
The state appealed, and an appellate court disagreed with the judge, reversing his ruling in a 14 page decision. The teen can now be tried as an adult, and the case moves from family court to a grand jury.
Both the accused teen and the girl at the center of the case are minors, so neither is named here. The accusations have not been proven in court.
Made to order and shipped to your door.



