Was Michael Strahan’s Cheating What Caused Nicole Murphy To Call Off Engagement

There has been a lot of speculation as to what cased Nicole Murphy to call of her engagement to Michael Strahan. One rumor is that between their busy schedules and the fact that Michael lived in New York and Nicole in Los Angeles, the couple just didn’t have time for each other.  Another rumor is that they had been broken up for weeks and because Nicole knew Strahan would not be inviting her to his NFL Hall of Fame induction ceremony, she broke the news the day before. Today, the rumor is that Michael had been cheating on Nicole and she had been investigating his filthy ways. 

Via TMZ

Nicole Murphy decided to tell the world she had broken up with Michael Strahan — right when he was entering the Hall of Fame — because that’s when she “confirmed” he was unfaithful.

A source close to the couple tells TMZ … Nicole first got wind Michael might be dating another woman in early July and started investigating … the way scorned women do. We’re told she was finally convinced it was true on Friday  and immediately decided to go public.

The source did not know the nature of Nicole’s proof.

We’re told Nicole insists her timing wasn’t out of revenge, rather a total coincidence because that’s when she knew for sure. It just happened to come precisely when Michael was getting the greatest honor of his career.

Other sources tell us Nicole and Michael have been broken up for several weeks — and, in fact, their bi-coastal relationship has been on and off for almost 2 years … since Michael took the ‘Live’ gig.

Ultimately this may come down to that old “Friends” theory — but we’re told Nicole definitely did NOT think they were “on a break.”

Relationships are super complicated. They could have broken up due to none of these things or all of them. Until someone speaks up, I guess we’ll never know.